1 week later
Sue lies on the carpet in her living room, ear pressed to the floor.
She can hear Greta.
Growling.
Moaning like a sick, dying animal.
Thrashing against her restraints.
Sue fumbles for her phone…
She texts Ed.
Sue
Sue
Where are you??
Ed
Ed
I’m standing in line at the store about to pay.
Sue
Sue
Did you remember to buy all the other things?
Sue
Sue
Paint and a ladder and tools so it doesn’t look suspicious?
Ed
Ed
Yes!
Sue
Sue
You better have.
Sue
Sue
We can’t look suspicious. No one can know what’s going on.
Sue
Sue
We can’t get caught.
Ed
Ed
I KNOW!
Ed
Ed
Let me remind you that you started this.
Ed
Ed
You were the one who tied her up and gagged her in the first place.
Sue
Sue
She was going to cut our baby out!
Ed
Ed
I know. But in the process, you’ve turned this into a kidnapping.
Sue
Sue
You’re just as involved in this as I am.
Sue
Sue
Besides, I wasn’t the one who sedated her and locked her in the basement today.
Ed
Ed
She ate through the duct tape on her wrists and broke out of the bedroom.
Sue
Sue
See?
Sue
Sue
We’re in this together.
Ed
Ed
God Almighty! I’m a doctor.
Ed
Ed
This goes against everything I believe in and have trained for my entire adult life.
Sue
Sue
She’s carrying OUR baby.
Ed
Ed
I know. But there’s got to be another way to do this!
Ed
Ed
Are we really going to chain her to a bed in the basement until she gives birth?
Sue
Sue
We’ve tried everything else.
Sue
Sue
Negotiating. Begging. Pleading.
Sue
Sue
Greta doesn’t respond like other people do.
Ed
Ed
That’s what I’m worried about.
Ed
Ed
What’s going to happen when she wakes up now and finds herself tied to a bed in a basement?
Sue
Sue
What happens if she doesn’t?
Sue
Sue
She tried to slam her belly against a wall today.
Sue
Sue
She’s going to kill our baby. Or herself.
Ed
Ed
I know. I know.
Ed
Ed
I guess we’re saving the baby, and saving her from herself.
Sue
Sue
Exactly.
Ed
Ed
This doesn’t make us bad people. Does it?
Sue
Sue
No! These are extraordinary circumstances.
Ed
Ed
You’re right. They are.
Sue
Sue
How long is that sedative meant to work for?
Ed
Ed
Another half-hour.
Sue
Sue
Hurry, she’s waking up, I can hear her moving!!!
Ed
Ed
Okay.
3 days later
Sue climbs up the ladder into the living room.
She slams the trapdoor shut.
It locks with a loud click.
She flops onto her back and stares at the ceiling.
The feel of the soft carpet against her back momentarily relieves some tension.
The pull of the floor makes her want to close her eyes and drift off.
Drift away from all of this.
But she can’t.
There’s still too much they need to do…
Her phone pings.
She sits up and takes it out of her pocket.
It’s Ed.
Ed
Ed
Has she eaten yet?
Sue
Sue
No. She’s still refusing any food.
Ed
Ed
This isn’t good.
Sue
Sue
She’s trying to kill herself and the baby again.
Sue
Sue
What are we going to do?
Ed
Ed
We have to do whatever it takes to save Lilly.
Sue
Sue
OMG.
Sue
Sue
Lilly????
Sue
Sue
You decided?
Ed
Ed
Lilly-Anne Jefferies.
Sue
Sue
It sounds perfect.
Ed
Ed
Lilly-Anne. Our daughter.
Sue
Sue
Our “adopted” daughter.
Ed
Ed
Of course.
Ed
Ed
Have you told all your friends we’re on the adoption list?
Sue
Sue
Yes. They’re all so excited.
Sue
Sue
I told them it’s a closed adoption, so we won’t know who the parents are.
Ed
Ed
Good.
Ed
Ed
We need to keep our story straight.
Ed
Ed
No one can find out about this.
Sue
Sue
I know.
Sue
Sue
I still don’t know what we’re going to do after Greta gives birth.
Sue
Sue
What if she goes straight to the police?
Sue
Sue
What if she won’t leave?
Sue
Sue
What if we have to keep her in our basement forever?
Ed
Ed
We’ll cross that bridge when we get to it.
Ed
Ed
I’m also selling off some of my practice and those stocks.
Ed
Ed
By the time Lilly is born, we should have enough money to buy her silence.
Sue
Sue
We’re going to have a baby, Ed.
Sue
Sue
A baby girl!
Ed
Ed
I know.
Sue
Sue
I can’t wait.
Ed
Ed
We have to get her eating, though.
Sue
Sue
I’ve tried everything.
Ed
Ed
I’ll bring home a feeding tube today.
Ed
Ed
Doctors use it on anorexics who won’t eat.
Ed
Ed
It goes up the nose and straight into the stomach.
Sue
Sue
Do you really think that’s necessary?
Sue
Sue
I don’t want to torture her.
Ed
Ed
She’s tied to a bed in the basement…
Ed
Ed
She’s wearing diapers.
Sue
Sue
Will it hurt?
Ed
Ed
It will hurt more if she starves herself to death.
6 months later
It’s summer.
The afternoon sun suffuses the house with a warm glow.
Ed loves this time of day.
When he’s not at work, he’s home with Lilly.
His daughter.
Her entry into the world might not have been ideal.
In fact, it was far, far from it.
But every morning, when Ed picks Lilly up out of the cot, he makes a silent promise to her…
I’ll love you forever.
I’ll give you the best life possible.
And I’ll make sure you never see Greta again…
A promise he is sure he can keep, until he hears the sounds of breaking glass.
Five minutes later, Ed texts Sue.
Ed
Ed
GRETA’S GOT LILLY.
Ed
Ed
She’s got our baby girl.
Sue
Sue
What??
Sue
Sue
What are you talking about?
Sue
Sue
We haven’t seen Greta in months. Not since she took the money and left.
Ed
Ed
She just broke into the house and stormed into the nursery.
Ed
Ed
She says she wants her baby back.
Sue
Sue
LILLY IS NOT HER BABY!!
Sue
Sue
She’s our baby. We love her.
Sue
Sue
WE are her parents.
Ed
Ed
She has a knife!!!
Sue
Sue
What?! Get Lilly away from her!!!
Sue
Sue
Ed, please. Get Lilly.
Ed
Ed
She locked me in the basement.
Sue
Sue
WHAT??
Ed
Ed
She threatened to cut Lilly’s throat if I didn’t go into the basement.
Ed
Ed
What could I do?
Sue
Sue
You have to get out of there!
Ed
Ed
The locking system we installed only opens from the outside. You know that.
Sue
Sue
OMG OMG OMG.
Sue
Sue
Where is she now?
Ed
Ed
I can hear her upstairs.
Ed
Ed
She’s singing a lullaby to Lilly.
Sue
Sue
Ed, we need to call the police.
Ed
Ed
We can’t!
Sue
Sue
We have to. She could kill Lilly.
Ed
Ed
NO!
Ed
Ed
We held your twin sister captive in the basement.
Ed
Ed
We force-fed her, we sedated her, we tied her down.
Ed
Ed
She gave birth in a basement and then we stole her baby.
Sue
Sue
OH, GOD.
Sue
Sue
The police will take Lilly away from us. Won’t they?
Ed
Ed
Yes! We’ll go to jail and our baby will go into foster care.
Sue
Sue
We can’t let that happen.
Ed
Ed
As soon as you get home, come and open the basement.
Ed
Ed
I’m going to talk to her — try and keep her distracted.
Sue
Sue
Okay. I’m almost there.
Ed
Ed
I have one last vial of sedative in the fridge.
Ed
Ed
The needle is there in the medicine cabinet. Get it!
Sue
Sue
Okay. I will.
Ed
Ed
Hurry.
2 minutes later
Ed
Ed
SUE!!!??
Ed
Ed
Talk to me.
Ed
Ed
What’s going on? I hear a scuffle.
Ed
Ed
Sue??? Lilly’s crying, are you okay???
Ed
Ed
Can’t you hear me calling??
Ed
Ed
OH, GOD!
Ed
Ed
What was that thump?????
Ed
Ed
SUE?????
Ed
Ed
SUE????
Sue
Sue
Ed…
Ed
Ed
Thank God. Are you okay?
Ed
Ed
Is Lilly okay?
Sue
Sue
We’re fine…
Sue
Sue
But Greta isn’t.
Ed
Ed
What? Why?
Sue
Sue
I think I just killed her, Ed!
Sue
Sue